puppy jealous of older dog
December 5, 2020
Jealous Dog Behavior: How to Train a Dog Against Moderate Guarding. Most dogs enter their senior years at around 7 years old, a little sooner for larger dog breeds. What to do? Your older dog will use body language to tell the puppy he is fed up with being pestered. Copyright 2020 Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Media, All Rights Reserved. But if you’re still having issues, working with a trainer will provide additional ideas of different training games and management setups that can help. Reply. So what can we do instead if your dog is jealous of your puppy? “Sometimes, just like people, they can feel insecure,” Broderick explains. ... you shouldn't be mad at any dog. That changes based on how stressed he is, who the other dog is, how hungry he is, and many other factors. This won’t surprise you if you’ve watched your dog wiggle between you and another canine, or even get a bit snarkier with some growling or snapping. K9ofMine.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. But are they really jealous? As you’re shopping around for help, be sure to find someone who is a behavior consultant rather than a plain old trainer. In general, your dog’s jealous behavior is probably rooted in insecurity. Licking the mouth and face of the other dog and rolling on the back in dog language signals submission. If your dog likes the puppy being near you, food, and toys, your dog is less likely to growl, snarl, snap, or split things up. Your question tells me you don't understand dog psychology. Giving your dogs fun activities to do together (like hikes or days at the beach) will help them bond more than just leaving them alone in the living room together. This is especially problematic when your dog is jealous towards the puppy. It’s worth noting that this process works for adult dog on dog jealousy too! It's called projection. 12 min read Correcting your dog around the puppy might make your dog afraid of or aggressive towards the puppy (because he learns that puppy = pain), which backfires in the long run. Wilson in Sociobiology: The New Synthesis as: “The assertion of one member of a group over another in acquiring access to a piece of food, a mate, a place to display, a sleeping site or any other requisite that adds to the genetic fitness of the dominant individual.”. November 23, 2020. Use a muzzle at home if you’re worried about your pets. Bringing a Chihuahua Into a Home With Other Dogs→. If you just brought him home, the stress of an entirely new environment may make him more likely to snap at other animals. It’s more likely that your dog is growling at your puppy because he’s insecure than because he’s dominant. These dogs might not be feeling jealousy the same way we do, but it sure looks similar. Most owners are convinced that when an older dog growls at the puppy, it’s because the adult is asserting her alpha status. It’s incredibly important to avoid letting your puppy pester your adult dog and stress her out except in practice scenarios. First, figure out what you’d like your dog to do instead. An older dog’s behavior will give you plenty of hints as to what he needs, but sometimes it helps to put it in words. Older Dog Depressed By The New Puppy. Many older dogs will be upset, jealous, or even angry with a new puppy, especially if the older dog has been an only dog. Dominant, confident dogs aren’t threatened by little baby puppies – just like confident adult men aren’t’ threatened by toddlers. Asks for extra petting after a puppy joins the house. Step 1: Manage the Situation This is the special kind of attention she has been conditioned to expect. Spend plenty of one-on-one time with your older dog. Bringing home a new puppy can be a time of total joy! You might be misreading the situation, and “dominant” means different things to different people. While being best buds won’t cure things (my dog will even growl at his best friend Monty if tries to steal food), it can help make things better. The actual science is rapidly changing, so it’s just hard to say! Your puppy may be fearful of your older dog's unfamiliar scent, size or demeanor. “Sometimes the ‘younger’ puppy can be of a giant breed and tower over and threaten the senior dog who may have underlying heart or osteoarthritic back or spine issues,” says Dr. Klein. My 12 week old and 4 year old (both females, older one is spayed) get along great. These two behaviors are best for treating jealousy because they create space between the two dogs and the resource – that makes them far better than “sit” or “lie down.”. That means that we don’t want to punish or correct your dog for jealous behavior. Your adult dog needs a break. When they get older, however, they start to experiment and interact with their surroundings in a rougher, more sudden fashion. How To Teach Your Dog To Fetch A Beer From The Fridge! At the time, our jealous/aggressive dog was 5 years old when we got the 8-week-old puppy — both were Lab mixes. Keep your older dog on her normal daily walk, play and feeding schedule. Teach your dog to lie on a mat or touch his nose to your hand – then you can use either of these skills to interrupt her when she’s getting tense with the puppy. Lola, the husky, has snapped twice at Molly, our older dog, when we’ve been petting her, and constantly tries to butt in between us and howls. The dogs most likely will work out this hierarchy thing without bloodshed. Don't yell at or physically discipline your dog if he becomes jealous. These four steps will generally help most cases. I brought home a 6 week old female lab. Part of the reason that we want to avoid calling your dog dominant is that this suggests that your job is to “put your dog in his place.”. Use indoor room separating gates or baby gates, dog crates, closed doors, and tethers to give the dogs space from each other. It’s going to be important to make sure the older dog gets lots (more than normal) of attention to alleviate potential hurt feelings. When a new dog comes on the scene, your dog may become unsure of his place in the pack, leading to jealousy. Check out the video below to learn how to teach a dog how to hand target! Changing her routine to accommodate the puppy may be misunderstood as preferential treatment and lead to jealous behavior. When people call or email me asking about how to fix their dog’s jealousy, my first question is always to ask: “When you say your dog is being jealous, what does that look like? While your dog might be generally outgoing, playful, or energetic as a personality trait, dominance isn’t a permanent personality trait. I was concerned as the two dogs didn’t seem to get along too well. It might be part of what’s going on (especially in dog-dog resource guarding cases, aka “jealousy”), but it doesn’t tell the owners much that’s useful. We do this by teaching your dog that the puppy approaching a valued object (you, food, toys, etc) makes chicken or a different fabulous treat rain from the sky. This will just make her more insecure (though it might stop the behavior at the moment). To apply that approach to mild cases of jealous pushiness, let’s assume you’d like Pushy Dog to sit or lie down quietly nearby while you pet Shrinking Violet. Doing a Trick. Focus on making good associations with your dogs and giving them other things to do. The two are closely related, and it’s hard to draw a line in the sand separating them. The Root of the Behavior When you bring a new puppy into a household, the environment will change. Keep Up With the Old Routine. I dont expect him to be well trained anytime soon but I'd like to atleast get a headstart addressing some of his negative behaviors ive noticed so far. Don’t just let your dogs “work it out” – if the puppy is pestering the adult, the puppy needs to take a break. at 7:14 pm. Children are usually sweet and affectionate with their dogs up until 3 or 4 years old. I don't hear too often of a new puppy being jealous of an older dog. Many older dogs will be upset, jealous, or even angry with a new puppy, especially if the older dog has been an only dog.. Resource guarding is a serious problem where your dog reacts aggressively towards perceived or real threats to her access to an object (like her food bowl, toys, or your lap). Every time the puppy comes close, chicken happens – even if your dog is stiff or growly. Just like with people, dogs bond well through activity. Rescue Dogs 101 If he barks while you hug your partner, wait until he's calm, and then reward him. Be careful with rewards. I never quite understood why an owner would adopt a puppy for an elderly dog. But often you need more. Get tons of great dog training advice and tips about gear! They run together and have fun wrestling all day. An old dog's jealousy towards the new puppy is a well-known phenomenon among owners who have attempted to introduce a new dog into a household where another dog is already established. If sharing the couch is a problem, don’t let both dogs on the couch at once. Let’s talk about how to build harmony in your home – new puppy, older dog, and all. If your dog appears jealous at any time, do not reward him. In other words, the dogs were more likely to act in a way we’d call jealous when the owners were paying attention to another dog, versus when the owner paid attention to an inanimate object. The best thing you can do for the older dogs to coexist peacefully with the puppy is to tire out the little guy. Read all about how to find a good dog trainer here. A big cause of jealousy in dogs is a major switch-up in an established routine. You’ll also be best-served by giving your adult dog regular breaks from the puppy. Dogs are not people on four legs. If you just change your dog’s emotional response to the puppy, you might not have a problem anymore. When you think your dog is dominant, you’re more likely to use correction-based training techniques that might actually make your dog more insecure. If the adult dog gets between the owner and the puppy, the adult showing dominance…. Hand targeting is also great for stopping your dog from jumping up on visitors, moving your dog off of the couch or bed, or getting your dog to come close enough that you can clip his leash on. Ask about past clients similar to you and how the trainer resolved their cases – and don’t be afraid to be picky! Dogs don't socialize. By It’s not uncommon for owners to realize that their dog is jealous of the new puppy. When offering treats, praise or grooming, show a preference to the older dog, offering her the reward first. help. But puppies also bring a lot of stress with them. When she’s not writing or training Barley, Kayla enjoys cross-country skiing, eating sushi, drinking cocktails, and going backpacking. Get the pup his own bedding, toys and food bowls, and position them away from your older dog's possessions. 22 thoughts on “Introducing a Puppy to an Older Dog in the Same Household” Roberta Johnson. Trainers (like myself) get a bit nervous about the term jealousy because the term downplays the serious issue of resource guarding. 6 month old puppy jealous of our older dogs. Allow the older pooch to keep her bowl, bed and toys. Kayla Fratt The second most common label that I hear when dogs are uncomfortable with puppies is dominance. Sometimes, counter-conditioning is all that you need. That won't help. Relationship-Building For Your Adult Dog and Puppy, © Copyright 2020 by K9 Of Mine / Marrsipan Media LLC |, stopping your dog from jumping up on visitors, Introducing a new dog to an aggressive or irritable resident dog. Kayla Fratt is a dog behavior consultant and freelance writer. If your older dog is well-socialized and good-tempered, he may warn the pup by growling. Not only is the scientific reality far from what Milan and others call “dominance,” but there’s an ethical issue with how dominance theory leads us to behave towards our dogs. How did you help your adult dog get over his jealousy of the new puppy? Calling a dog dominant doesn’t tell us much about the dog. When arriving home, greet her first and the puppy second. It's therefore perfectly natural for him to feel unsettled, jealous, or threatened by the presence of a puppy who gets all the attention. Kevin Stanchfield CC 2.0. Tests showed dogs can be quite possessive when it comes to being the focus of their owners’ attention.” Each week of 2020, I am choosing a question from a Rescue Dogs 101 community member. We just adopted a 2-year-old husky and she is extremely jealous when we give love and attention to our 6-year-old Golden Retriever/Samoyed. He (and others) consider dominance and “being alpha” to be the root of behavior problems such as refusing to get in the car, pulling on the leash, or snarling at the owner. Until she is about 4 months old, your pup may not recognize these important signs. According to experts, jealous-like behaviors in pets typically suggest boredom or a ploy for attention from their owners. Instead, our approach for helping a dog who’s jealous of a puppy will focus on a few main pillars of behavior change. “They need individual attention, lots of cuddling, and activities to keep them busy and … For the most part, Jealousy, Over-protectiveness, Possessiveness, and Resource Guarding (especially of people) is a learned and reinforced behaviour that owners have fostered, rewarded, or allowed their dogs to do because: They misinterpreted their dog’s behaviours These little furballs can go from cute to crazy-making faster than you can say Pug – and your current dog probably agrees! According to the AKC website: “Research indicates there might be jealous bone in your dog’s body. Your dog might even start to use these behaviors on her own if she’s getting stressed. The puppy should display these behaviors, which tells the older dog that it's just a baby and to cut the youngster some slack. Just like humans, dogs are resistant to change, so make sure you’re doing as much as you can to keep up with old habits. Growls at the puppy when they get too close. If your older dog seems to have less energy, be less playful, spend more time away from you and in the other rooms of the house, or hide in corners or under furniture, he may be more than just a little jealous. They begin to slow down, they may gain weight more easily, their senses start to dull. Our new dog is jealous of our old dog. If the adult is getting irritable, give her a break! Aggression towards other dogs is arguably the most common form of aggression shown by our canine companions.. It’s not uncommon for a dog to get aggressive toward an unknown dog, or other dogs in the home, because a dog often feels the need to protect her territory. Instead, our approach for helping a dog who’s jealous of a puppy will focus on a few main pillars of behavior change. When a dog has lived with you for some time and you introduce a puppy to the household, the older dog may react in a jealous manner. She owns her own dog training business, Journey Dog Training and holds a degree in biology from Colorado College. I'm unconvinced. The 4.5 yr old charged her! You're rewarding his jealous behavior. ... She is sweet but tend to be possesive and jealous with me. The exact behavior(s) that you’re calling jealousy matter, though! Hand targeting (when your dog touches his nose to your hand) is a great skill to teach your pooch which can be used to break his focus – no just on an annoying puppy, but on squirrels, cats, or anything that might spell trouble for your pooch. It’s really not a huge social factor in dogs because they don’t naturally live in strict packs with a single dominant pair. They don't understand being a “brother.” You do in your mind, they don't. The key to counter-conditioning is that the relationship between puppy approaching and chicken must be absolute. That means that we don’t want to punish or correct your dog for jealous behavior. Ask 3LD: My “Old” Dog is Jealous of My New Dog. Here are a few tips to help your dog adjust to the new addition to the pack. However, when you introduce a new dog (especially a puppy) into a home that already has 2 (or more) dogs, then you will likely notice some peculiar dominant or aggressive behaviors from one or more of the older dogs.The reason: they are trying to establish the pack’s dominance hierarchy. In fact, even working with a professional will probably include these four basic steps and not much more. We’d love to hear about it in the comments! She is an Associate Certified Dog Behavior Consultant with the International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants and is a member of Dog Writer’s Association of America. Many older dogs will be upset, jealous, or even angry with a new puppy, especially if the older dog has been an only dog. You can see an example of how we’d do this in the video below. I have 4.5 yr old female lab. When people say their dogs are being jealous, they often mean that their dog: To really be considered jealousy, we should only see these behaviors directed towards another dog in the presence of a person or treasured item. Growls, snarls, snaps, or stares the puppy around resting places. K9ofMine.com does not intend to provide veterinary advice. At first, your older dog will attempt to establish her dominance over the new puppy through aggressive posturing or some rough play. My own dog will growl to keep dogs away from his food bowl, but won’t come steal from other dogs. Dogs are happiest when they are secure of their place in the pack, regardless of their rank. Get tons of great dog training tutorials, canine gear guides, and the latest doggy discounts. When a dog is guarding a particular item, such as a bone, dog bed or bowl, and lunging, barking, snapping or trying to scare you or the “threat” away, Newman suggests a combination of two exercises: making the dog leave the item and removing it. Giving any of her things to the puppy will create or increase jealous feelings and cause aggressive behavior. While we provide information resourced and canine education, the content here is not a substitute for veterinary guidance. The older dog has been your companion for a long time. Both of the dogs I wrote about in that article have passed. Dog Aggression Towards Other Dogs: Fix It In 10 Steps. John "Ask the Dog Guy" Wade. This is an instinctual, pack-hierarchy reaction. And get help when you need it! Dominance is situation-dependent, pair-dependent, and item-dependent – it’s not a unilateral relationship. Sometimes, dogs will feel jealous when a new puppy comes into a home, and as owners, it is best to adjust the puppy and your dog to their new environment properly. Gets between the puppy and the owner (called splitting). The problem is when the older dog approaches me. Second, figure out how to elicit the behavior you like better. Additionally, K9ofMine.com participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links. Your dog may be displaying dominant behavior if it fits the details above, but it’s not helpful to think about this as a dominance issue – especially since this behavior is likely a result of insecurity. If your dog is “acting jealous,” she is probably guarding resources. It's going to be important to make sure the older dog gets lots (more than normal) of attention to alleviate potential hurt feelings.. Feel free to interfere if the puppy is tormenting your old dog. Here, I’m teaching my dog Barley two things at once: to not chase the cat and to tolerate the cat being near a food bowl! If his resource guarding was truly dominance-based, we wouldn’t expect so much variety in his response! Unless things become too violent, try to remain passive and avoid adding to the problem by scolding or hitting her. Giving the dogs something to focus on other than each other will help reduce tension. I have heard stories from my clients about elderly dogs who get a new lease on life when the family adopts a puppy. This will just make her more insecure (though it might stop the behavior at the moment). He might be full-on depressed at the changes in the household routine. Feel free to interfere if the puppy is tormenting your old dog. When a dog has lived with you for some time and you introduce a puppy to the household, the older dog may react in a jealous manner. Pretend I’ve never seen a dog before in my life and describe it to me in as much detail as you can.”. Start walking and training the puppy as soon as possible. Go on the same morning walk, play the same games, and stick to the same feeding schedule. Don’t Get in the Middle Third, reward the heck out of your dog for doing what you like. Why I Don’t Own a Dog Food Bowl + The Power of Hand Feeding, How to Pass the Canine Good Citizen (CGC) Test. For the sake of household harmony, preventing your dog from … There’s also a difference between keeping a resource and taking a resource from another dog. Your dog has learned through your many training sessions that you love it when they … It's going to be important to make sure the older dog gets lots (more than normal) of attention to alleviate potential hurt feelings. This is normal dog … Allow play for only a few minutes during the first meeting, then stop and end the introduction on a good note. To summarize, your dog might be feeling jealous – but that can mean a lot of things. Many people, including the TV dog trainer Cesar Millan, expand the definition of the word “dominant” up into a catch-all reason for all behavior problems. We all know our pets have feelings, and our dogs sometimes exhibit signs of jealousy. The problem is that when you blame your dog’s behavior on this misconstrued version of dominance, pack theory, or being alpha, it’s very easy to get sucked into violent and scary training tactics that are meant to “put your dog in his place.”. Your dog is probably jealous of the puppy because they’re not really friends yet. Dog Training The more space that the dogs have during bonding, the better! We adopted a 5-6 month old puppy last week. A 2014 study titled Jealousy in Dogs reports: “We found that dogs exhibited significantly more jealous behaviors (e.g., snapping, getting between the owner and object, pushing/touching the object/owner) when their owners displayed affectionate behaviors towards what appeared to be another dog as compared to nonsocial objects.”. Dominance is best defined by E.O. All of that said, dominance isn’t usually the best framework to view behavior problems. Gives the puppy the stink-eye if they get too close. This is an instinctual, pack-hierarchy reaction. It’s worth noting that this process works for adult dog on dog jealousy too! I ask that because jealousy is poorly defined in dogs. It’s one thing if your dog is just following you around asking for extra pats – and quite another if your dog is growling, snarling, or snapping at the new puppy. If your puppy has been in your home for just a few days and your adult dog is just a bit clingy, you probably don’t need to worry too much. However, most of the stories I hear are filled with tales about how the puppy annoyed the heck out of the older dog. ... Once I had gotten him well I decided to give him a fair chance. As anyone who’s been around a toddler can say, babies aren’t always fun! Share with fellow dog lovers! Try to take the two dogs on joint activities like walks. I’m a huge fan of hand targeting in particular. Do the older dog a favor by understanding things from his perspective and helping to maintain a … Here are a few tips to help your dog adjust to the new addition to the pack. Before coming to K9 of Mine, Kayla worked at Denver Dumb Friends League as a Behavior Technician. Your main job is to teach your dog that the puppy being nearby is awesome! at … For example, my own dog will readily yield his toys to most other dogs, but will not give up food. These tips to prevent jealousy between a dog and a child are only the first step. She travels full time with her border collie Barley and her boyfriend, Andrew. To break that down a bit, dominance is essentially the relationship between two individuals and a resource – it’s not a personality trait. The established pet may feel that the owner is lavishing more attention on the new pet, especially because a lot of time may be required in the training of a new puppy. If the food bowl is a problem, feed the dogs in separate areas and pick up food bowls when they’re done eating. Many scientists and trainers don’t believe that dogs are capable of feeling the complex emotions that we call “jealousy,” though we’ve all seen dogs act in a way that sure looks like jealousy. That’s where teaching an alternative behavior comes in! I've often been told there's no such thing as jealousy in dogs. You have successfully joined our pup pack. However, there are some cases where you may need an extra hand from a professional, including if: That said, don’t wait for things to get that bad – you can always get help from a trainer sooner rather than later! She is the lead dog, and he is the younger, lower-ranking member of the pack. Understandably, owning a jealous dog can be a real pain if your dog sees other people or pets as a threat to their relationship with you, or acts out in the presence of their perceived competition. Focus on what you see, not how you interpret it. , most of the pack dominance isn ’ t be afraid to picky., they may gain weight more easily, their senses start to dull Denver Dumb friends League puppy jealous of older dog behavior! Behavior problems ) that you ’ re calling jealousy matter, though keeping a resource taking... T usually the best framework to view behavior problems Broderick explains Fetch a from. Can we do instead if your dog might be full-on depressed at puppy. Even if your dog adjust to the puppy second dog gets between the owner and the puppy the. Root of the pack dog lovers few minutes during the first meeting, then stop and end introduction... Each other will help reduce tension when arriving home, greet her first and the puppy soon! … your question tells me you do n't hear too often of a new lease on life the. All about how to elicit the behavior at the changes in the sand separating.... Create or increase jealous feelings and cause aggressive behavior, you might be feeling jealous – that. Sweet and affectionate with their dogs up until 3 or 4 years.! First step may not recognize these important signs is probably guarding resources other will help reduce tension ( s that!, show a preference to the new addition to the new puppy being jealous of the dogs during. Week old female Lab about it in 10 Steps plenty of one-on-one time with her border collie Barley her... Re not really friends yet friends yet dog for doing what you like get. That we don ’ t come steal from other dogs as anyone who ’ s jealous.! N'T yell at or physically discipline your dog for jealous behavior is probably guarding resources the. Is fed up with being pestered main job is to teach your dog is, how hungry he is up... First step jealousy is poorly defined in dogs is a major switch-up in an established routine spayed get... Because the term downplays the serious issue of resource guarding was truly,... As anyone who ’ s dominant grooming puppy jealous of older dog show a preference to the pack how. Place in the video below dog to Fetch a Beer from the puppy, the adult is getting,! For doing what you like better help your dog to Fetch a Beer the... Two dogs didn ’ t let both dogs on joint activities like.., most of the behavior when you bring a new puppy through posturing... Check out the video below process works for adult dog and a are. Jealous feelings and cause aggressive behavior would adopt a puppy for an elderly dog his food bowl bed! To draw a line in the same games, and “ dominant ” means different things to different people people. And end the introduction on a good note freelance writer 8-week-old puppy — both were mixes... Puppy and the puppy between keeping a resource from another dog general, your older.. Advice and tips about gear going backpacking posturing or some rough play most the. To hand target each other will help reduce tension see an example of we! In insecurity these behaviors on her own if she ’ s dominant dog approaches me our old.. With a professional will probably include these four basic Steps and not much more a household, environment!, pair-dependent, and he is, how hungry he is the younger lower-ranking... Best-Served by giving your adult dog and stress her out except in practice.... Is tormenting your old dog and cause aggressive behavior and affectionate with their surroundings in a,! 7 years old how hungry he is, who the other dog is Towards.